PLASTIC PLUMBING ISSUE YES OR NO?
Some time in 2009, and then again at the end of 2009, I came across a concern with a newer plastic plumbing system while conducting a Minneapolis home inspection. The first thing I noticed was corrosion around a fitting in the furnace room of the home. Now this did not alarm me in anyway, but I made a note that the clamp and connection should be checked. Then I found another in the same room and another.. See where I am going. Now could this have all been an installation issue, possibly! But even so, then what is going on behind the walls.. So I decided to do a little research on the type of fittings involved. (Zurn Pex Plastic Plumbing/ Brass Fittings)

In my quest to uncover what may be the cause I came across the following information on Zurn Pex plastic plumbing and fittings:
( http://www.zurnclassaction.com/)
( http://newsblaze.com/story/2007081013504600001.pz/topstory.html )
(http://www.plumbingsupply.com/pex.html ) and a more resent 2010 article
( http://www.alawpro.com/lawyer-attorney-1553652.html ).
Now the argument can be made that maybe lawyers are out for blood.. But what about the fact that there are enough people affected to make a class action suit. The concern seems to be with "dezincification" or the which means the brass is stripped of the anti-corrosive ability. I have heard many variations of this process and what may be causing it. Some say it is do to Well systems and others say it may be too much Chlorine. Regardless, there needs to be some more evaluation into this potential problem. We do not want another Polybutylene disaster like in the 80's-90's. That plastic plumbing system was suppose to be the latest and greatest as well and instead came to be a builders, and home owners, nightmare. So some caution does need to be generated with these systems, especially since it is relatively new and we do know the long term ability of such systems and some concerns have already been raised. So what to do as a Home Inspector?
Well, I have brought this concern to the attention of other home inspectors, some of whom have brought it to the attention of their local chapter. I have repeatedly put the same informational links in my reports pertaining to the Zurn Pex brass systems as is in this blog. I feel if the buyer is informed of the potential concerns that exist and no one can make a clear case as to what is causing the failures, then the buyer needs to make a decision for themselves on just what they are willing to take on. I can not make that decision for them, but I can inform them of a potential problem and point them toward the information. I know many home inspectors are not doing this and I feel this is a shame. Buyers need to be informed of potential concerns such as this just as if there were a potential fire hazard, does mean you will have a fire, but you could!
Final note is that Zurn Pex discontinued sale of their brass fittings in Minnesota altogether. Currently you will find most of the Zurn Systems installed will have the black plastic fittings. Numerous manufacturers of plastic plumbing systems exist, and to date, I have not experienced or heard of concerns with other systems (not that there can't be).
If you would like more information or to schedule a Minneapolis Home Inspection (we cover the 11 county metro area) call us @ 612-919-3844 or email us @ sevencounty@yahoo.com. Our website address is www.7countyhomeinspection.com or www.homeinspectorsminneapolis.com
Some time in 2009, and then again at the end of 2009, I came across a concern with a newer plastic plumbing system while conducting a Minneapolis home inspection. The first thing I noticed was corrosion around a fitting in the furnace room of the home. Now this did not alarm me in anyway, but I made a note that the clamp and connection should be checked. Then I found another in the same room and another.. See where I am going. Now could this have all been an installation issue, possibly! But even so, then what is going on behind the walls.. So I decided to do a little research on the type of fittings involved. (Zurn Pex Plastic Plumbing/ Brass Fittings)
In my quest to uncover what may be the cause I came across the following information on Zurn Pex plastic plumbing and fittings:
( http://www.zurnclassaction.com/)
( http://newsblaze.com/story/2007081013504600001.pz/topstory.html )
(http://www.plumbingsupply.com/pex.html ) and a more resent 2010 article
( http://www.alawpro.com/lawyer-attorney-1553652.html ).
Now the argument can be made that maybe lawyers are out for blood.. But what about the fact that there are enough people affected to make a class action suit. The concern seems to be with "dezincification" or the which means the brass is stripped of the anti-corrosive ability. I have heard many variations of this process and what may be causing it. Some say it is do to Well systems and others say it may be too much Chlorine. Regardless, there needs to be some more evaluation into this potential problem. We do not want another Polybutylene disaster like in the 80's-90's. That plastic plumbing system was suppose to be the latest and greatest as well and instead came to be a builders, and home owners, nightmare. So some caution does need to be generated with these systems, especially since it is relatively new and we do know the long term ability of such systems and some concerns have already been raised. So what to do as a Home Inspector?
Well, I have brought this concern to the attention of other home inspectors, some of whom have brought it to the attention of their local chapter. I have repeatedly put the same informational links in my reports pertaining to the Zurn Pex brass systems as is in this blog. I feel if the buyer is informed of the potential concerns that exist and no one can make a clear case as to what is causing the failures, then the buyer needs to make a decision for themselves on just what they are willing to take on. I can not make that decision for them, but I can inform them of a potential problem and point them toward the information. I know many home inspectors are not doing this and I feel this is a shame. Buyers need to be informed of potential concerns such as this just as if there were a potential fire hazard, does mean you will have a fire, but you could!
Final note is that Zurn Pex discontinued sale of their brass fittings in Minnesota altogether. Currently you will find most of the Zurn Systems installed will have the black plastic fittings. Numerous manufacturers of plastic plumbing systems exist, and to date, I have not experienced or heard of concerns with other systems (not that there can't be).
If you would like more information or to schedule a Minneapolis Home Inspection (we cover the 11 county metro area) call us @ 612-919-3844 or email us @ sevencounty@yahoo.com. Our website address is www.7countyhomeinspection.com or www.homeinspectorsminneapolis.com






